- Nearly a third of young women (30%) do not get feedback after a job interview, compared to less than a fifth (18%) of male applicants.
- Half of young women who had a bad recruitment experience say it knocked their confidence – but just a third of young men say the same
Young women are far less likely than young men to receive feedback after a job interview, research by the City & Guilds Group and Business in the Community (BITC) has revealed.
The survey of 4,000 young people (18-24 year olds) found that young women are at a stark disadvantage in recruitment practices. While 82% of young men receive feedback after applying, just under a third (30%) of young women are losing out on this vital constructive guidance. For young people applying for a job for the first time, constructive feedback can help them learn from their experiences, improve their applications and access future employment.
Young women generally found the experience of applying for a job more difficult, with 34% saying it was difficult versus just a quarter of men (26%). Of those who found the application process difficult, young women were more likely to say it knocked their confidence (49% vs 37% respectively). A quarter said the experience made them less likely to apply for other jobs, while 73% said it affected them generally, higher than for young men.
The findings make clear the importance of employers recognising the cost of poor recruitment processes, as a fifth of young women who had a bad experience said they were put off a company entirely. A further 11% said a bad experience put them off an entire industry, meaning valuable talent could be lost.
The findings follow earlier research by City & Guilds – part of the City & Guilds Group – into career expectations, which found that teenage girls expect to earn an annual salary of £36,876 within ten years of leaving education, 16% less than that their male peers expect to earn.
Other key findings include:
- Only 37% of young women who did receive feedback said it was good, compared to 45% of men
- Young men were more likely to do mock interviews than women (24% versus 17%)
- Young women were more likely to prioritise working with friendly and helpful colleagues / managers than men (42% versus 30%)
- NEETS are further disadvantaged in the recruitment process, with 40% not getting any feedback, compared to 29% of all young people
- 70% of applicants in London were given feedback, compared to 60% in the South East and 48% in Northern Ireland
Speaking about the findings, Mikki Draggoo, Corporate Relations Director of the City & Guilds Group, said: ‘This research shows that the gender gap exists even at the start of women’s careers. And that isn’t just harming young women – it affects businesses too. Employers could be missing out on talented women without even realising it, which is why they need to examine their recruitment practices and make sure they are inclusive. That kind of transparency will yield better talent for businesses – essential in our climate of slow growth and stagnant productivity. Employers can’t afford to lose talented employees before they even start their careers.’
Grace Mehanna, Director of Talent & Skills, BITC, said: ‘Not providing feedback can have a damaging effect on confidence levels for young people. We recognise that it’s hard for employers with a high volume of applicants to provide individual feedback, but we would urge them to take a staged approach. For candidates who aren’t shortlisted, you can offer collective general yet informative feedback such as ‘top tips for applying’; alongside more tailored feedback for those who make it to interview. Our Future Proof campaign is asking employers to offer all young candidates some form of useful feedback, no matter what their background, race or gender.’
Amy King, Head of Consulting at the Chemistry Group, said: ‘It's shocking and disappointing to hear of statistics in 2016 that present a bleak reality of women lacking equality in the workplace, especially so early on in their careers. Despite awareness and progress over the past few decades, it indicates that recruitment is still riddled with bias. Organisations who look past gender by objectively defining 'what great looks like' specific to their roles and build processes to recruit and nurture talent against this are best placed to combat this issue. All of a sudden gender becomes irrelevant. Those who do, see better diversity and better business results. It seems that this only tackles half the problem, the second it is to address the self-perceptions, expectations and confidence of young women. This is best achieved by creating inclusive and supportive environments whilst giving women an opportunity to have voice, influence, and respect in the workplace. If we can achieve that, we'll not only help our mums, daughters, sisters, aunts and friends but our society will ultimately prosper.’
The survey was carried out as part of Future Proof, a campaign and framework from Business in the Community (BITC) that’s backed by the City & Guilds Group to help businesses break down the barriers young people face in their recruitment processes.
The campaign aims to work with businesses to make recruitment processes more inclusive, fair and transparent. Not having open and transparent recruitment process can be a real barrier and deterrent for young applicants, and businesses could be missing out on recruiting the best young talent into their workforce.
As part of the framework, BITC has produced a guide for businesses on how they can make their recruitment processes more transparent for young people, including practical advice on how to offer constructive feedback to young candidates. The resources also include best practice case studiesfrom organisations that are developing open and accessible recruitment processes to engage a broad range of applicants. Employers can also get a free bespoke report on their youth employment strategy.
Notes to editor
About the City & Guilds Group
- The City & Guilds Group is a leader in global skills development. Its purpose is to enable people and organisations to develop their skills for personal and economic growth.
- Backed by a Royal Charter, the City & Guilds Group has over 135 years’ experience in making sure that people are prepared to contribute to successful businesses and thriving economies.
- The City & Guilds Group partners with more than 200 companies to develop the skilled workforces that they need, and invests in learning technologies to help people learn whenever and wherever they can.
- The City & Guilds Group is made up of City & Guilds, ILM, City & Guilds Kineo and The Oxford Group:
- City & Guilds develops programmes of learning, learning technology, certification and assessment, to support colleges, training providers and governments.
- ILM helps individuals, education providers and businesses improve the standards of leadership and management through qualifications, accredited training and specialist member services. ILM awards qualifications to over 95,000 managers across the world every year.
- City & Guilds Kineo is a global workplace learning company. It offers a fresh approach to elearning management systems, apprenticeships and managed learning services.
- The Oxford Group provides bespoke management training, leadership development and executive coaching to the world's leading companies.
- Combined, the City & Guilds Group operates in over 100 countries, through 10,000 training centres, delivering qualifications in 26 different industries.
- For more information about the City & Guilds Group visit: www.cityandguildsgroup.com
About Business in the Community (BITC)
- Business in the Community is the Prince’s Responsible Business Network.
- Our members work together to tackle a wide range of issues that are essential to building a fairer society and a more sustainable future.
- Responsible business is about how a business makes its money not just how it spends its profit. It is about managing growth responsibly while reducing dependency on natural resources. It is about how the business operates as an employer, supplier and customer and how as a neighbour it helps to create vibrant communities where people can flourish. We are a business-led, issue focused charity with more than 30 years’ experience of mobilising business. We engage thousands of businesses through our programmes driven by our core membership of over 800 organisations from small enterprises to global corporations.
- BITC run the Annual Workplace Gender Equality Awards, one of the UK's only workplace awards for gender equality and inclusion. Winners of this year’s awards will be announced on 20th April, as part of Responsible Business Week 2016.